Skip to page content

Gold Coast property blog

Cheaper homes, bigger falls: why small-deposit buyers are exposed

Buying a cheaper home can feel like the safer choice. But a new report shows some cheaper markets fell faster in September than one of Sydney's richest areas.

The Nightly's 26 October report, using Ray White's Neoval figures, puts Ipswich and Logan-Beaudesert down 1.4% for the month. Sydney's eastern suburbs rose 0.2%.

That is the twist behind the 7NEWS headline. The lower price tag did not mean a smaller fall in those markets that month.

Two risks can land on the same buyer

The first risk is the home losing value. The second is having very little of your own money in it.

With a small deposit, there is less room for the price to fall before the loan is bigger than the home's value. A modest fall can use up the buyer's whole deposit.

Imagine an $800,000 home bought with $40,000 down and a $760,000 loan. If its value falls 5%, the home is worth $760,000. The deposit has gone on paper.

If the value falls 10%, it is worth $720,000. Against the starting loan, there is a $40,000 shortfall.

This example holds the loan unchanged. Paying it down improves the position; selling costs make the amount needed to leave higher.

Help to buy does not remove price risk

The government's 5% deposit scheme can help eligible buyers purchase without lenders mortgage insurance. Its guarantee is for the lender. It does not promise the buyer a resale price.

That distinction matters. Getting the keys sooner can be useful, but it does not create the same buffer as putting in a larger deposit.

Does this mean buyers must sell?

No. The RBA's October review estimates fewer than 1% of borrowers are in negative equity. Being below zero does not itself mean a borrower cannot keep paying.

The squeeze becomes much harder if income stops or a move cannot wait. Selling then may leave a debt instead of cash for the next home.

What this headline tells us

The report is a warning about exposed buyers and particular markets. It is not a measured fall for every Australian home, or a Gold Coast price report.

My view: the debate gives getting into the market far more attention than the buffer left after buying. Both matter. A cheaper home with a large loan can still leave its owner badly exposed.

For the step-by-step explanation, read What happens if you owe more than your home is worth? It shows why a price fall and a forced sale are different problems.

Related: What happens if you owe more than your home is worth?

Sources